• Announcements

    • r0naLd222

      Looking for GFX Peepz!   10/18/2016

      Karaholic needs GFX (Graphic Artists). If you are interested, please message me or @flamestalker , @Yongery or @Lupang
    • flamestalker

      [NEW] Member Solo Activities Subforums!   03/11/2017

      Hey Karaholic! Since all of the members are now with different agencies, we thought it'd be appropriate to create new subforums so members can stay in touch with their activities. Please try to post here from now on with future updates and events.  Here are the new subforums we've created:
      Park Gyuri: http://www.karaholic.com/forums/index.php?/forum/158-park-gyuri-solo-activities-motion-media/
      Han Seungyeon: http://www.karaholic.com/forums/index.php?/forum/159-han-seungyeon-solo-activities-jwide/
      Goo Hara: http://www.karaholic.com/forums/index.php?/forum/157-goo-hara-solo-activities-keyeast/
      Jung Nicole: http://www.karaholic.com/forums/index.php?/forum/160-jung-nicole-solo-activities-b2m/
      Kang Jiyoung: http://www.karaholic.com/forums/index.php?/forum/161-kang-jiyoung-solo-activities-sweetpower/ For Youngji, we've opted to leave the forum as is as she is still with DSP Media.  Thanks for your attention, hope you continue to drop by and visit.. new members and old! 

      -KH Staff
geop

KARA MV Individual Screentime Statistics [Updated June 13, 2011]

76 posts in this topic

[June 13, 2011]

Version 1.02: added Jet Coaster Love (Close-up ver.), added KARA5 Deviation section

[April 3, 2011]

Version 1.00: added Jumping (Japanese ver.), added Jumping (Smart Sports ver.), added Jumping (Korean ver.), added Jet Coaster Love

Version 0.78: added We're With You, added Mister, added 2Me

Version History

[March 30, 2011]

Version 0.12: added Break It, added If U Wanna

[March 31, 2011]

Version 0.24: added Rock U, added Pretty Girl

[April 1, 2011]

Version 0.36: added Good Day: Season 2, added Honey

[April 2, 2011]

Version 0.60: added Same Heart, added Wanna, added Lupin

After calculating the total screentime for every single MV for each member of another girl group (can you guess which one? :P), I wondered if my beloved KARA suffered from the same virus that plagued SoShi MVs (I calculated a huge gap between members' screen time... Jessica Jung, who I calculated to have the highest amount of screentime, has around 200 seconds more screentime than Kim Hyoyeon, who has the lowest amount...).

So here are my results... so far. I'll be updating this as frequently as possible, chronologically going through all of KARA's MVs.

I calculated the time by using all the frames in the music video and converting it to seconds using the frames per second (fps) of the video file.

For the most part, any scene that held ALL members was not counted, unless there was blatant focus on a specific member. If there WAS a blatant focus, that scene would only count for the member that the camera was focused on. If you have any other questions about what I counted, or if something seems wrong, just ask.

Sunghee Era

Break It

Solo scenes

SUNGHEE: 528 frames @ 30fps -> 17.60 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 510 frames @ 30fps -> 17.00 seconds

GYURI: 248 frames @ 30fps -> 8.27 seconds

NICOLE: 177 frames @ 30fps -> 5.90 seconds

Non-solo scenes

GYURI: 747 frames @ 30fps -> 24.90 seconds

SUNGHEE: 541 frames @ 30fps -> 18.03 seconds

NICOLE: 442 frames @ 30fps -> 14.73 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 324 frames @ 30fps -> 10.80 seconds

Total

SUNGHEE: 1069 frames @ 30fps -> 35.63 seconds

GYURI: 995 frames @ 30fps -> 33.17 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 834 frames @ 30fps -> 27.80 seconds

NICOLE: 619 frames @ 30fps -> 20.63 seconds

If U Wanna

Solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 725 frames @ 30fps -> 24.17 seconds

NICOLE: 492 frames @ 30fps -> 16.40 seconds

SUNGHEE: 472 frames @ 30fps -> 15.73 seconds

GYURI: 470 frames @ 30fps -> 15.67 seconds

Non-solo scenes

NICOLE: 883 frames @ 30fps -> 29.43 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 735 frames @ 30fps -> 24.50 seconds

GYURI: 722 frames @ 30fps -> 24.07 seconds

SUNGHEE: 500 frames @ 30fps -> 16.67 seconds

Total

SEUNGYEON: 1460 frames @ 30fps -> 48.67 seconds

NICOLE: 1375 frames @ 30fps -> 45.83 seconds

GYURI: 1192 frames @ 30fps -> 39.73 seconds

SUNGHEE: 972 frames @ 30fps -> 32.40 seconds

Sunghee Era Solo and Non-solo totals

Solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 41.17 seconds

SUNGHEE: 33.33 seconds

GYURI: 23.93 seconds

NICOLE: 22.30 seconds

Non-solo scenes

GYURI: 48.97 seconds

NICOLE: 44.17 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 35.30 seconds

SUNGHEE: 34.70 seconds

Sunghee Era Grand Totals

xYoya.png -> 76.47 seconds

oPHbr.png -> 72.90 seconds

Az9pU.png -> 68.03 seconds

45cHi.png -> 66.47 seconds

KARA5 Era

Rock U

Solo scenes

JIYOUNG: 282 frames @ 30fps -> 9.40 seconds

HARA: 281 frames @ 30fps -> 9.37 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 231 frames @ 30fps -> 7.70 seconds

GYURI: 216 frames @ 30fps -> 7.20 seconds

NICOLE: 173 frames @ 30fps -> 5.77 seconds

Non-solo scenes

GYURI: 1158 frames @ 30fps -> 38.60 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 1102 frames @ 30fps -> 36.73 seconds

NICOLE: 763 frames @ 30fps -> 25.43 seconds

HARA: 562 frames @ 30fps -> 18.73 seconds

JIYOUNG: 457 frames @ 30fps -> 15.23 seconds

Total

GYURI: 1374 frames @ 30fps -> 45.80 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 1333 frames @ 30fps -> 44.43 seconds

NICOLE: 936 frames @ 30fps -> 31.20 seconds

HARA: 843 frames @ 30fps -> 28.10 seconds

JIYOUNG: 739 frames @ 30fps -> 24.63 seconds

Pretty Girl

Solo scenes

HARA: 677 frames @ 30fps -> 22.57 seconds

GYURI: 482 frames @ 30fps -> 16.07 seconds

NICOLE: 434 frames @ 30fps -> 14.47 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 333 frames @ 30fps -> 11.10 seconds

JIYOUNG: 333 frames @ 30fps -> 11.10 seconds

Non-solo scenes

NICOLE: 921 frames @ 30fps -> 30.70 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 894 frames @ 30fps -> 29.80 seconds

JIYOUNG: 659 frames @ 30fps -> 21.97 seconds

GYURI: 593 frames @ 30fps -> 19.77 seconds

HARA: 398 frames @ 30fps -> 13.27 seconds

Total

NICOLE: 1355 frames @ 30fps -> 45.17 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 1227 frames @ 30fps -> 40.90 seconds

GYURI: 1075 frames @ 30fps -> 35.83 seconds

HARA: 1075 frames @ 30fps -> 35.83 seconds

JIYOUNG: 992 frames @ 30fps -> 33.07 seconds

Good Day: Season 2

Solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 661 frames @ 30fps -> 22.03 seconds

GYURI: 605 frames @ 30fps -> 20.17 seconds

HARA: 560 frames @ 30fps -> 18.67 seconds

NICOLE: 498 frames @ 30fps -> 16.60 seconds

JIYOUNG: 427 frames @ 30fps -> 14.23 seconds

Non-solo scenes

NICOLE: 752 frames @ 30fps -> 25.07 seconds

GYURI: 746 frames @ 30fps -> 24.87 seconds

JIYOUNG: 624 frames @ 30fps -> 20.80 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 551 frames @ 30fps -> 18.37 seconds

HARA: 484 frames @ 30fps -> 16.13 seconds

Total

GYURI: 1351 frames @ 30fps -> 45.03 seconds

NICOLE: 1250 frames @ 30fps -> 41.67 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 1212 frames @ 30fps -> 40.40 seconds

JIYOUNG: 1051 frames @ 30fps -> 35.03 seconds

HARA: 1044 frames @ 30fps -> 34.80 seconds

Honey

Solo scenes

NICOLE: 497 frames @ 30fps -> 16.57 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 414 frames @ 30fps -> 13.80 seconds

HARA: 375 frames @ 30fps -> 12.50 seconds

JIYOUNG: 328 frames @ 30fps -> 10.93 seconds

GYURI: 287 frames @ 30fps -> 9.57 seconds

Non-solo scenes

NICOLE: 626 frames @ 30fps -> 20.87 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 525 frames @ 30fps -> 17.50 seconds

GYURI: 499 frames @ 30fps -> 16.63 seconds

HARA: 432 frames @ 30fps -> 14.40 seconds

JIYOUNG: 425 frames @ 30fps -> 14.17 seconds

Total

NICOLE: 1123 frames @ 30fps -> 37.43 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 939 frames @ 30fps -> 31.30 seconds

HARA: 807 frames @ 30fps -> 26.90 seconds

GYURI: 786 frames @ 30fps -> 26.20 seconds

JIYOUNG: 753 frames @ 30fps -> 25.10 seconds

Same Heart

Solo scenes

JIYOUNG: 338 frames @ 30fps -> 11.27 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 290 frames @ 30fps -> 9.67 seconds

NICOLE: 246 frames @ 30fps -> 8.20 seconds

GYURI: 225 frames @ 30fps -> 7.50 seconds

HARA: 213 frames @ 30fps -> 7.10 seconds

Non-solo scenes

GYURI: 620 frames @ 30fps -> 20.67 seconds

JIYOUNG: 440 frames @ 30fps -> 14.67 seconds

NICOLE: 271 frames @ 30fps -> 9.03 seconds

HARA: 175 frames @ 30fps -> 5.83 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 167 frames @ 30fps -> 5.57 seconds

Total

GYURI: 845 frames @ 30fps -> 28.17 seconds

JIYOUNG: 778 frames @ 30fps -> 25.93 seconds

NICOLE: 517 frames @ 30fps -> 17.23 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 457 frames @ 30fps -> 15.23 seconds

HARA: 388 frames @ 30fps -> 12.93 seconds

Wanna

Solo scenes

JIYOUNG: 427 frames @ 30fps -> 14.23 seconds

GYURI: 407 frames @ 30fps -> 13.57 seconds

NICOLE: 391 frames @ 30fps -> 13.03 seconds

HARA: 301 frames @ 30fps -> 10.03 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 291 frames @ 30fps -> 9.70 seconds

Non-solo scenes

JIYOUNG: 674 frames @ 30fps -> 22.47 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 614 frames @ 30fps -> 20.47 seconds

HARA: 570 frames @ 30fps -> 19.00 seconds

GYURI: 495 frames @ 30fps -> 16.50 seconds

NICOLE: 489 frames @ 30fps -> 16.30 seconds

Total

JIYOUNG: 1101 frames @ 30fps -> 36.70 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 905 frames @ 30fps -> 30.17 seconds

GYURI: 902 frames @ 30fps -> 30.07 seconds

NICOLE: 880 frames @ 30fps -> 29.33 seconds

HARA: 871 frames @ 30fps -> 29.03 seconds

Lupin

Solo scenes

NICOLE: 950 frames @ 30fps -> 31.67 seconds

HARA: 696 frames @ 30fps -> 23.20 seconds

JIYOUNG: 512 frames @ 30fps -> 17.07 seconds

GYURI: 508 frames @ 30fps -> 16.93 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 463 frames @ 30fps -> 15.43 seconds

Non-solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 466 frames @ 30fps -> 15.53 seconds

HARA: 364 frames @ 30fps -> 12.13 seconds

NICOLE: 358 frames @ 30fps -> 11.93 seconds

JIYOUNG: 258 frames @ 30fps -> 8.60 seconds

GYURI: 159 frames @ 30fps -> 5.30 seconds

Total

NICOLE: 1308 frames @ 30fps -> 43.60 seconds

HARA: 1060 frames @ 30fps -> 35.33 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 929 frames @ 30fps -> 30.97 seconds

JIYOUNG: 770 frames @ 30fps -> 25.67 seconds

GYURI: 667 frames @ 30fps -> 22.23 seconds

We're With You

Solo scenes

HARA: 371 frames @ 30fps -> 12.37 seconds

JIYOUNG: 355 frames @ 30fps -> 11.83 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 348 frames @ 30fps -> 11.60 seconds

GYURI: 330 frames @ 30fps -> 11.00 seconds

NICOLE: 321 frames @ 30fps -> 10.70 seconds

Non-solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 456 frames @ 30fps -> 15.20 seconds

GYURI: 369 frames @ 30fps -> 12.30 seconds

NICOLE: 288 frames @ 30fps -> 9.60 seconds

HARA: 178 frames @ 30fps -> 5.93 seconds

JIYOUNG: 128 frames @ 30fps -> 4.27 seconds

Total

SEUNGYEON: 804 frames @ 30fps -> 26.80 seconds

GYURI: 699 frames @ 30fps -> 23.30 seconds

NICOLE: 609 frames @ 30fps -> 20.30 seconds

HARA: 549 frames @ 30fps -> 18.30 seconds

JIYOUNG: 483 frames @ 30fps -> 16.10 seconds

Mister

Solo scenes

JIYOUNG: 454 frames @ 30fps -> 15.13 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 387 frames @ 30fps -> 12.90 seconds

GYURI: 384 frames @ 30fps -> 12.80 seconds

HARA: 375 frames @ 30fps -> 12.50 seconds

NICOLE: 339 frames @ 30fps -> 11.30 seconds

Non-solo scenes

NICOLE: 944 frames @ 30fps -> 31.47 seconds

GYURI: 722 frames @ 30fps -> 24.07 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 402 frames @ 30fps -> 13.40 seconds

HARA: 302 frames @ 30fps -> 10.07 seconds

JIYOUNG: 263 frames @ 30fps -> 8.77 seconds

Total

NICOLE: 1283 frames @ 30fps -> 42.77 seconds

GYURI: 1106 frames @ 30fps -> 36.87 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 789 frames @ 30fps -> 26.30 seconds

JIYOUNG: 717 frames @ 30fps -> 23.90 seconds

HARA: 677 frames @ 30fps -> 22.57 seconds

2Me

Solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 882 frames @ 30fps -> 29.40 seconds

GYURI: 606 frames @ 30fps -> 20.20 seconds

NICOLE: 497 frames @ 30fps -> 16.57 seconds

JIYOUNG: 284 frames @ 30fps -> 9.47 seconds

HARA: 185 frames @ 30fps -> 6.17 seconds

Non-solo scenes

JIYOUNG: 1193 frames @ 30fps -> 39.77 seconds

HARA: 1179 frames @ 30fps -> 39.30 seconds

NICOLE: 928 frames @ 30fps -> 30.93 seconds

GYURI: 882 frames @ 30fps -> 29.40 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 338 frames @ 30fps -> 11.27 seconds

Total

GYURI: 1488 frames @ 30fps -> 49.60 seconds

JIYOUNG: 1477 frames @ 30fps -> 49.23 seconds

NICOLE: 1425 frames @ 30fps -> 47.50 seconds

HARA: 1364 frames @ 30fps -> 45.47 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 1220 frames @ 30fps -> 40.67 seconds

Jumping (Japanese ver.)

Solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 354 frames @ 24fps -> 14.75 seconds

NICOLE: 212 frames @ 24fps -> 8.83 seconds

HARA: 202 frames @ 24fps -> 8.42 seconds

JIYOUNG: 185 frames @ 24fps -> 7.71 seconds

GYURI: 164 frames @ 24fps -> 6.83 seconds

Non-solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 545 frames @ 24fps -> 13.40 seconds

HARA: 536 frames @ 24fps -> 10.07 seconds

JIYOUNG: 372 frames @ 24fps -> 8.77 seconds

GYURI: 404 frames @ 24fps -> 24.07 seconds

NICOLE: 372 frames @ 24fps -> 31.47 seconds

Total

SEUNGYEON: 899 frames @ 24fps -> 37.46 seconds

HARA: 738 frames @ 24fps -> 30.75 seconds

JIYOUNG: 646 frames @ 24fps -> 26.92 seconds

NICOLE: 584 frames @ 24fps -> 24.33 seconds

GYURI: 568 frames @ 24fps -> 23.67 seconds

Jumping (Smart Sports ver.)

Total

HARA: 661 frames @ 30fps -> 22.03 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 653 frames @ 30fps -> 21.77 seconds

JIYOUNG: 566 frames @ 30fps -> 18.87 seconds

NICOLE: 426 frames @ 30fps -> 14.20 seconds

GYURI: 373 frames @ 30fps -> 12.43 seconds

Jumping (Korean ver.)

Solo scenes

HARA: 386 frames @ 24fps -> 16.08 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 366 frames @ 24fps -> 15.25 seconds

NICOLE: 247 frames @ 24fps -> 10.29 seconds

JIYOUNG: 239 frames @ 24fps -> 9.96 seconds

GYURI: 193 frames @ 24fps -> 8.04 seconds

Non-solo scenes

HARA: 575 frames @ 24fps -> 23.93 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 503 frames @ 24fps -> 20.96 seconds

GYURI: 462 frames @ 24fps -> 19.25 seconds

NICOLE: 371 frames @ 24fps -> 15.46 seconds

JIYOUNG: 349 frames @ 24fps -> 14.54 seconds

Total

HARA: 961 frames @ 24fps -> 40.04 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 869 frames @ 24fps -> 36.21 seconds

GYURI: 655 frames @ 24fps -> 27.29 seconds

NICOLE: 618 frames @ 24fps -> 25.75 seconds

JIYOUNG: 588 frames @ 24fps -> 24.50 seconds

Jet Coaster Love

Solo scenes

NICOLE: 439 frames @ 30fps -> 14.63 seconds

JIYOUNG: 430 frames @ 30fps -> 14.33 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 344 frames @ 30fps -> 11.47 seconds

GYURI: 288 frames @ 30fps -> 9.60 seconds

HARA: 260 frames @ 30fps -> 8.67 seconds

Non-solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 996 frames @ 30fps -> 33.20 seconds

HARA: 974 frames @ 30fps -> 32.47 seconds

GYURI: 948 frames @ 30fps -> 31.60 seconds

NICOLE: 878 frames @ 30fps -> 29.27 seconds

JIYOUNG: 818 frames @ 30fps -> 27.27 seconds

Total

SEUNGYEON: 1340 frames @ 30fps -> 44.67 seconds

NICOLE: 1317 frames @ 30fps -> 43.90 seconds

JIYOUNG: 1248 frames @ 30fps -> 41.60 seconds

GYURI: 1236 frames @ 30fps -> 41.20 seconds

HARA: 1234 frames @ 30fps -> 41.13 seconds

Jet Coaster Love (Close-up ver.)

Solo scenes

NICOLE: 41.77 seconds

GYURI: 29.40 seconds

JIYOUNG: 26.10 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 25.13 seconds

HARA: 19.63 seconds

Non-solo scenes

SEUNGYEON: 56.47 seconds

GYURI: 53.50 seconds

NICOLE: 52.97 seconds

HARA: 49.20 seconds

JIYOUNG: 44.77 seconds

Total

NICOLE: 94.73 seconds

GYURI: 82.90 seconds

SEUNGYEON: 81.60 seconds

JIYOUNG: 70.87 seconds

HARA: 68.83 seconds

KARA5 Solo and Non-solo totals

Solo scenes

45cHi.png220.39 seconds

xYoya.png209.93 seconds

oPHbr.png188.88 seconds

cnHDV.png187.27 seconds

BMsQg.png182.77 seconds

Non-solo scenes

oPHbr.png329.28 seconds

45cHi.png324.53 seconds

xYoya.png317.17 seconds

cnHDV.png282.76 seconds

BMsQg.png276.48 seconds

KARA5 Grand Totals

45cHi.png559.12 seconds

xYoya.png548.87 seconds

oPHbr.png530.59 seconds

cnHDV.png492.06 seconds

BMsQg.png478.12 seconds

KARA5 Grand Total Deviation

45cHi.png[+37.37] seconds

xYoya.png[+27.12] seconds

oPHbr.png[+8.84] seconds

xpU1g.png [521.75] seconds

cnHDV.png[-29.69] seconds

BMsQg.png[-43.63] seconds

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

this is interesting <3

the difference isn't that big, well, it wasn't back in the day.

now i'm pretty sure hara has more screentime than everyone else.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

it's very interesting thread and I give a salute to you for working hard in compiling this data~ thumbs up for you! :thumbup:

As expected, there is not much difference of screentime between each member~ Anticipating for other statistic too~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

wow!!! very unexpected... :w00t:

this is very interesting for we all.....

glad they have no difference screentime....

thanks for sharing this.....keep it up... :thumbup1:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

this is interesting <3

the difference isn't that big, well, it wasn't back in the day.

now i'm pretty sure hara has more screentime than everyone else.

I... honestly have no idea. This would be the first time watching a lot of these MVs for me, to be honest.

I'd like to see if what you say is true. :s

Mm, thanks for the motivation, everyone. ^_^

Anyway, edited the first post with Rock U and Pretty Girl.

I'll probably be able to do a couple more MVs later today.

Edited by geop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So, Hara and jiyoung got the least screen time during rock u and pretty girl era? Maybe because they were just new in the group. haha.. there's a lot of prediction can be made from this statistic~ keep doing this! :thumbup1:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

wow! interesting and impressive work!

this must be really hard to do!

m. geop i salute you for your dedication!

question: are you going to work on all MVs?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is so cool. it gives a snapshot of the girls exposure on camera.

The good thing is that the difference isn't that big.

It must be a time consuming job. Very nice. Well done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting, i hope that everyone will get more balanced screen time even though it'll be quite hard. Kara Fighting

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You're so hardworking and patient. @_@

Oh cool! This is so interesting! >_< Seems like Ham gets the most screen time. Must be the Main vocals thing.

Right now, Hara may get MORE screen time but MVs also focus on who sings the lines so I'm guessing GyulHamCole will still get more time. I'm also guessing that Cole would get the most for Lupin and Ham for Honey. Hoohoo. Just guessing.

I wonder, did anyone do a "Total number of singing lines" too? But then... There are already a lot of songs. @_@ Maybe just the promoted songs will do.

Edited by KaiserKawaii

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Cool thread, Thanks for the data and all the hard-work.

I'll look forward to your updates~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you for sharing each girl's statistics...:)

You've really put effort on it!^^

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

question: are you going to work on all MVs?

Yes. I'm going by KARA's Discography page on Wikipedia. I hope nothing's missing from the chart that's on there...

You're so hardworking and patient. @_@

Oh cool! This is so interesting! >_< Seems like Ham gets the most screen time. Must be the Main vocals thing.

Right now, Hara may get MORE screen time but MVs also focus on who sings the lines so I'm guessing GyulHamCole will still get more time. I'm also guessing that Cole would get the most for Lupin and Ham for Honey. Hoohoo. Just guessing.

I wonder, did anyone do a "Total number of singing lines" too? But then... There are already a lot of songs. @_@ Maybe just the promoted songs will do.

Yeah, vocals will likely play a large part and it evidently does. But who knows. (When I did this for SNSD, Yoona, who has the minimum amount of lines in songs, had almost the most amount of screentime, while Tiffany (who has the 2nd or 3rd most lines) was 6th in screentime :s)

Anyway. Where does this all leave Jing!? D:

I'm too new of a fan to distinguish voices right now. D:

I think I have Nicole's and Gyuri's vocals down, though... :s

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

just saw this thread.. and it's a pretty impressive work :scared:

nice one :thumbup1:

naturally, there will always a member who stands out than the rest (esp in terms both of vocal talent and visual, which will give disadvantages for those who didn't fall to either categories)..

but i'm happy that KARA's distribution in MV didn't have that big difference, esp in KARA4 days..

that expected though, since KARA4 days have a more fair distribution, both in distribution of lines as well as mv appearance..

while since KARA5 days, everything have changed. but surprisingly, although HARA got the least line, she still got better MV appearance than jing..

i will anticipate more data later :lol:

u can ask around for more detailed info about the MV than wikipedia :P

btw, for distribution of line in the songs u can check songbox.

we have pretty much all of songs covered (except 1 song, since it's too hard for us).. if there are no mistake, that is.. the one who worked on it are humans too afterall :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

thank you for the figures, especially they are compiled after exhausted scanning through the thousands of frames.

you desire to receive a compliment for this.

yup i'm pretty sure harajing will catch up in the latter mvs.

can't wait for your next updates.

btw how do you decide the (redblue) colors for harajing? lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@curbow oh hey, thanks~

indeed. AND, Hara also has the most solo screentime. You can argue that solo screentime has a bigger impact than total screentime. And... that still leaves Jing at the bottom. Hopefully she catches up...

and thanks for the heads-up on the line distribution~

@red4summer I wasn't sure what Hara's or Jing's favourite colour was, haha. :blushing:

Do you know what they are? Because I really wasn't sure what colours to pick for them, so I just gave them colours that weren't already taken...

Oh, and I've updated the first post with Good Day: Season 2 and Honey.

These first 4 KARA5 MVs liked having scenes with only the original 3 on-screen. It's weird. :s

Edited by geop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Very cool post geop. I can't wait for the final results. I do have a question. Are you counting non-singing parts for MV's? Like in the beginning of 'Wanna' where Jiyoung is talking on the phone.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Very cool post geop. I can't wait for the final results. I do have a question. Are you counting non-singing parts for MV's? Like in the beginning of 'Wanna' where Jiyoung is talking on the phone.

Yes, I am.

The only kinds of scenes I wouldn't count are scenes like this:

GvOML.jpg

Scenes like this show all members and there isn't really any focus on one member, so I usually don't count it. Any other scene is counted, whether there's singing or not.

Edited by geop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@geop

about their colors, i'm wanting to know too. hahah. btw since you're registered in karaholic, you can goto more reliable or most updated source here than wikipedia for mv listing. (oops, i just realized jcl is not updated yet.)

though pretty sure as mentioned earlier, i really hope the gaps are not widening anymore. jing to make a comeback!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@geop

about their colors, i'm wanting to know too. hahah. btw since you're registered in karaholic, you can goto more reliable or most updated source here than wikipedia for mv listing.

though pretty sure as mentioned earlier, i really hope the gaps are not widening anymore. jing to make a comeback!

Ah, yes. I couldn't go there before because I didn't have 15 posts yet, but I've been using it now, thanks. :)

It's very convenient~

As for the colours... I went by the profiles here at KH.

The profile said that Gyuri's favourite colour is purple, so I used purple.

Ham's profile said that her favourite colour was pink, so I used pink.

Hara's profile said that her favourite colour was ALSO pink, so I just gave her the closest colour... red.

Nicole's profile says "Orange & Blue Purple" but since Gyuri's colour is also purple and since Gyuri is older, I gave purple to Gyuri and gave Nicole orange, even though it was crossed out. >.<

Jing's favourite colour... was not stated in her profile, so I just gave her blue, because no one else had blue. D:

Sunghee's profile says her favourite colour is green, so I gave her green.

Have their favourite colours changed? Are there colours that would be better to use?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

^

lol. no worries, red & blue are perfect. use them & keep up the good work!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

lmao geop, that is interesting..

before me and my team worked on the songbox coloring, i made the same research with u too..by looking at the member's profile.

and the reason i chose orange for cole is similar too, since gyul already pick purple initially too..

both GoolJing never stated their face colors, unlike the rest..

but hara did like red lately. and if u pay attention, gool always matched with red in several occasions, while yep, jing are paired with blue too..

so i will say, WE make a good decision :lol:

back about screentime. it's understandable that Hara got more solo screentime. i would say she is in charge of visual in KARA. lol

and don't worry about jing, she got her momentum since lupin. she got more line and attention too. it's just a matter of time for her to shine :)

and the early KARA5's MV, it's a common practice to put more attention to the original members, since people know them more than the new members. then it will slowly shifted to the new members to introduce the new members to the audience :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

KYAA~~~this is so fun~~~><!!! screentime statistics~

omoo~

Ham got 1st place :gemadmire: wah~im so surprised with this~~~><!!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@curbow

Woah, really!? This sounds a little too crazy...

*checks the songbox*

omg, it's true!

woahhhh. great minds think alike, I guess. ^_^

it certainly seems that way for Hara...

yeah, Jing's already getting a pretty big increase in time.

Speaking of which...

I updated the first post with Same Heart, Wanna, and Lupin.

Same Heart and Wanna were both very good to JIYOUNG.

NICOLE has the most Solo screentime... for now. I'm sure HARA will take her spot back. @_@

Wanna is probably the most balanced MV so far, looking at what I calculated...

Edited by geop

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.